| Valley Litigators | AAMAC | Huntington Herd | Williamstown Shockers | |||||
| 1 | Darren Sproles, Kansas St. | RB | Walter Reyes, Syracuse | RB | Mark Clayton, Oklahoma | WR | Sonny Cumbie, Texas Tech | QB |
| 2 | Dan Orlovsky, Connecticut | QB | Chris Leak, Florida | QB | Taurean Henderson, Texas Tech | RB | Earl Charles, Marshall | RB |
| 3 | Chris Henry, West Virginia | WR | Braylon Edwards, Michigan | WR | Bruce Gradkowski, Toledo | QB | Nehemiah Glover, Texas Tech | WR |
| 4 | Wali Lundy, Virginia | RB | Reggie Brown, Georgia | WR | Josh Davis, Marshall | WR | Kejuan Jones, Oklahoma | RB |
| 5 | Greg Jennings, Western Mich. | WR | Fred Gibson, Georgia | WR | P.J. Pope, Bowling Green | RB | Dante Ridgeway, Ball St. | WR |
| 6 | Tyrone Moss, Miami (FL) | WR | Cedric Houston, Tennessee | RB | Ron Monteilh, Colorado | WR | Joshua Haldi, Northern Ill. | QB |
| 7 | Kyle Orton, Purdue | QB | Josh Allen, Maryland | RB | Chris Barclay, Wake Forest | RB | Jarrett Hicks, Texas Tech | WR |
| 8 | Tramain Hall, NC State | WR | Chris Rix, Florida St. | QB | Joshua Cribbs, Kent St. | QB | Brandon Jones, Oklahoma | WR |
| 9 | Brandon Williams, Wisconsin | WR | Jonathan Orr, Wisconsin | WR | Jared Parseghian, Miami (OH) | K | Ben Jones, Purdue | K |
| 10 | Nick Novak, Maryland | K | Jerod Void, Purdue | RB | Airese Currie, Clemson | WR | Trinity Dawson, Toledo | RB |
| 11 | Louisiana State Tigers | DT | Matt Leach, Florida | K | Mike Espy, Mississippi | WR | Heath Miller, Virginia | WR |
| 12 | Kregg Lumpkin, Georgia | RB | Jason Avant, Michigan | WR | A.J. Harris, Northern Illinois | RB | Laurence Maroney, Minnesota | RB |
| 13 | Charlie Whitehurst, Clemson | QB | Mike Nugent, Ohio St. | K | Marshall Thundering Herd | DT | Kansas State Wildcats | DT |
| 14 | Ross Pilkington, Nebraska | WR | Marcus Randall, LSU | QB | Jon Peattie, Miami (FL) | K | Darian Durant, North Carolina | QB |
| 15 | Andre Caldwell, Florida | WR | Ohio State Buckeye | DT | Tremel Guillory, Marshall | WR | Wisconsin Badgers | DT |
| 16 | Todd Pegram, Texas A&M | K | Jabari Davis, Tennessee | RB | Iowa Hawkeyes | DT | Dusty Mangum, Texas | K |
| 17 | Florida State Seminoles | DT | Ohio Bobcats | DT | Ahmad Bradshaw, Marshall | RB | Lorenzo Booker, Florida State | RB |
| 18 | Adrian Peterson, Oklahoma | RB | Troy Williamson, South Carolina | WR | Darrell Dowery, Kent State | WR | Ibrahim Haulsey, Illinois | RB |
| 19 | Tony Hunt, Penn State | RB | OJ Small, Florida | WR | Eric Deslauriers, Eastern Mich | WR | Todd Blythe, Iowa State | WR |
| 20 | Mark Philmore, Northwestern | WR | Ciatrick Fason, Florida | RB | Matt Prater, Central Florida | K | Adam Barmann, Kansas | QB |
| 21 | Cornell Brockington, Uconn | RB | Garrett Wolfe, Northern Illinois | RB | Steve Sanders, Bowling Green | WR | ||
| 22 | Courtney Roby, Indiana | WR | Chris Nendick, Northern Illinois | K | Pierre Thomas, Illinois | RB | ||
| 23 | Gavin Dickey, Florida | QB | Domenik Hixon, Akron | WR | John Randle, Kansas | RB | ||
| Charleston Chew | Warwood Warriors | Willow Island Wannabees | Marrietta Mustangs | |||||
| 1 | Anthony Davis, Wisconsin | RB | Cedric Benson, Texas | RB | Brad Smith, Missouri | QB | Carnell Williams, Auburn | RB |
| 2 | T.A. McLendon, NC State | RB | Kay-Jay Harris, West Virginia | RB | Justin Vincent, LSU | RB | Jason White, Oklahoma | QB |
| 3 | Lance Moore, Toledo | WR | Charlie Frye, Akron | QB | Marion Barber III, Minnesota | RB | Anthony Sherrell, Eastern Mich. | RB |
| 4 | Omar Jacobs, Bowling Green | QB | Rasheed Marshall, West Virginia | QB | Craphonso Thorpe, Florida St. | WR | Martin Nance, Miami (Ohio) | WR |
| 5 | Princell Brockenbrough, Pittsburgh | WR | Cole Magner, Bowling Green | WR | Stan Hill, Marshall | QB | Taylor Stubblefield, Purdue | WR |
| 6 | Michael Larkin, Miami (OH) | WR | Steve Odom, Toledo | WR | Jared Ellerson, Minnesota | WR | Tavaris Capers, UCF | WR |
| 7 | Courtney Lewis, Texas A&M | RB | Lydell Ross, Ohio St. | RB | Trey DiCarlo, Oklahoma | K | Vernand Morency, Oklahoma St. | RB |
| 8 | Skyler Green, LSU | WR | Charles Sharon, Bowling Green | WR | Keron Henry, Connecticut | WR | Isaiah Fluellen, Nebraska | WR |
| 9 | Brock Berlin, Miami (FL) | QB | Rhys Lloyd, Minnesota | K | Shaun Suisham, Bowling Green | K | Jason Robbins, Toledo | K |
| 10 | Aleks Miskov, Northern Illinois | K | Frank Gore, Miami (FL) | RB | Jerry Seymour, Central Mich. | RB | Vince Young, Texas | QB |
| 11 | Damien Nash, Missouri | RB | Ryan Moore, Miami (FL) | WR | Oklahoma Sooner | DT | Georgia Bulldog | DT |
| 12 | Bill Flowers, Mississippi | WR | Matt Herian, Nebraska | WR | Ronnie Brown, Auburn | RB | Mark Simmons, Kansas | WR |
| 13 | Joe Dailey, Nebraska | QB | Walter Washington, Temple | QB | David Greene, Georgia | QB | Shatone Powers, Northern Illinois | WR |
| 14 | Virginia Tech Hokies | DT | Jason Colson, West Virginia | RB | Hiram Moore, Marshall | WR | P.J. Daniels, Georgia Tech | RB |
| 15 | Xavier Beitia, Florida State | K | Texas Longhorns | DT | Ryan Hamby, Ohio State | WR | Jason Anderson, Wake Forest | WR |
| 16 | West Virginia Mountaineers | DT | Brandon Pace, Virginia Tech | K | Minnesota Golden Gophers | DT | Miami Hurricane | DT |
| 17 | Brian Leonard, Rutgers | RB | Noah Herron, Northwestern | RB | Andrew Clarke, Toledo | WR | BenJarvus Green-Ellis, Indiana | RB |
| 18 | Jason Campbell, Auburn | QB | Calvin Johnson, Ga Tech | WR | ||||
| 19 | Bristol Olomua, Texas Tech | WR | Josh Betts, Miami (OH) | QB | ||||
| 20 | Jason Williams, Connecticut | WR | Alex Trilica, Texas Tech | K | ||||
| 21 | Santonio Holmes, Ohio St | WR | Kenny Higgins, Toledo | WR | ||||
| 22 | Johnnie Mack, Texas Tech | RB | Trey Haverty, Texas Tech | WR | ||||
| 23 | Northern Illinois | DT | Brett Biggs, Akron | RB |