| Heisman Pts. | MOVFSA Team | Round | Pos | Player | NCAA Team |
| 159 | Huntington Herd | 3 | QB | Bruce Gradkowski | Toledo Rockets |
| 155 | Charleston Chew | 4 | QB | Omar Jacobs | Bowling Green Falcons |
| 149 | Williamstown Shockers | 1 | QB | Sonny Cumbie | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 140 | AAMAC | 3 | WR | Braylon Edwards | Michigan Wolverines |
| 127 | Warwood Warriors | 1 | RB | Cedric Benson | Texas Longhorns |
| 119 | AAMAC | 2 | QB | Chris Leak | Florida Gators |
| 114 | Williamstown Shockers | 5 | WR | Dante Ridgeway | Ball State Cardinals |
| 113 | Warwood Warriors | 4 | QB | Rasheed Marshall | West Virginia Mountaineers |
| 112 | Marietta Mustangs | 5 | WR | Taylor Stubblefield | Purdue Boilermakers |
| 105 | Valley Litigators | 5 | WR | Greg Jennings | Western Michigan Broncos |
| 102 | Charleston Chew | 3 | WR | Lance Moore | Toledo Rockets |
| 99 | Willow Island Wannabees | 3 | RB | Marion Barber III | Minnesota Golden Gophers |
| 96 | Valley Litigators | 3 | WR | Chris Henry | West Virginia Mountaineers |
| 96 | Warwood Warriors | 8 | WR | Charles Sharon | Bowling Green Falcons |
| 91 | Marietta Mustangs | 2 | QB | Jason White | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 89 | Marietta Mustangs | 7 | RB | Vernand Morency | Oklahoma State Cowboys |
| 88 | Valley Litigators | 4 | RB | Wali Lundy | Virginia Cavaliers |
| 86 | Huntington Herd | 19 | WR | Eric Deslauriers | Eastern Michigan Eagles |
| 83 | Huntington Herd | 2 | RB | Taurean Henderson | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 77 | Valley Litigators | 2 | QB | Dan Orlovsky | Connecticut Huskies |
| 77 | Williamstown Shockers | 7 | WR | Jarrett Hicks | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 77 | AAMAC | 20 | RB | Ciatrick Fason | Florida Gators |
| 75 | Huntington Herd | 21 | RB | Garrett Wolfe | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 74 | Valley Litigators | 1 | RB | Darren Sproles | Kansas State Wildcats |
| 68 | Williamstown Shockers | 12 | RB | Laurence Maroney | Minnesota Golden Gophers |
| 67 | Huntington Herd | 4 | WR | Josh Davis | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 67 | Charleston Chew | 11 | RB | Damien Nash | Missouri Tigers |
| 66 | AAMAC | 13 | K | Mike Nugent | Ohio State Buckeyes |
| 65 | Charleston Chew | 15 | K | Xavier Beitia | Florida State Seminoles |
| 63 | Willow Island Wannabees | 1 | QB | Brad Smith | Missouri Tigers |
| 62 | Willow Island Wannabees | 18 | QB | Jason Campbell | Auburn Tigers |
| 61 | Warwood Warriors | 5 | WR | Cole Magner | Bowling Green Falcons |
| 61 | Warwood Warriors | 9 | K | Rhys Lloyd | Minnesota Golden Gophers |
| 60 | Marietta Mustangs | 3 | RB | Anthony Sherrell | Eastern Michigan Eagles |
| 59 | AAMAC | 1 | RB | Walter Reyes | Syracuse Orangemen |
| 53 | Huntington Herd | 1 | WR | Mark Clayton | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 53 | Valley Litigators | 10 | K | Nick Novak | Maryland Terrapins |
| 50 | Huntington Herd | 5 | RB | P.J. Pope | Bowling Green Falcons |
| 46 | Charleston Chew | 17 | RB | Brian Leonard | Rutgers Scarlet Knights |
| 45 | Willow Island Wannabees | 8 | WR | Keron Henry | Connecticut Huskies |
| 45 | Marietta Mustangs | 9 | K | Jason Robbins | Toledo Rockets |
| 45 | Charleston Chew | 13 | QB | Joe Dailey | Nebraska Cornhuskers |
| 44 | Marietta Mustangs | 6 | WR | Tavaris Capers | Central Florida Golden Knights |
| 44 | Willow Island Wannabees | 9 | K | Shaun Suisham | Bowling Green Falcons |
| 43 | Marietta Mustangs | 16 | DT | Miami | Miami (FL) Hurricanes |
| 41 | Warwood Warriors | 6 | WR | Steve Odom | Toledo Rockets |
| 41 | Williamstown Shockers | 16 | K | Dusty Mangum | Texas Longhorns |
| 41 | Valley Litigators | 18 | RB | Adrian Peterson | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 39 | Charleston Chew | 2 | RB | T.A. McLendon | North Carolina State Wolfpack |
| 39 | Williamstown Shockers | 3 | WR | Nehemiah Glover | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 37 | AAMAC | 4 | WR | Reggie Brown | Georgia Bulldogs |
| 36 | Williamstown Shockers | 9 | K | Ben Jones | Purdue Boilermakers |
| 35 | Marietta Mustangs | 1 | RB | Carnell Williams | Auburn Tigers |
| 35 | Charleston Chew | 6 | WR | Michael Larkin | Miami (OH) RedHawks |
| 35 | Willow Island Wannabees | 12 | RB | Ronnie Brown | Auburn Tigers |
| 35 | AAMAC | 15 | DT | Ohio State | Ohio State Buckeyes |
| 35 | Warwood Warriors | 15 | DT | Texas | Texas Longhorns |
| 34 | Huntington Herd | 7 | RB | Chris Barclay | Wake Forest Demon Deacons |
| 33 | Valley Litigators | 7 | QB | Kyle Orton | Purdue Boilermakers |
| 33 | Marietta Mustangs | 19 | QB | Josh Betts, Miami (OH) | Miami (OH) Redhawks |
| 32 | Willow Island Wannabees | 6 | WR | Jared Ellerson | Minnesota Golden Gophers |
| 32 | Marietta Mustangs | 23 | RB | Brett Biggs | Akron Zips |
| 31 | Willow Island Wannabees | 11 | DT | Oklahoma | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 30 | Willow Island Wannabees | 7 | K | Trey DiCarlo | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 28 | AAMAC | 19 | WR | OJ Small | Florida Gators |
| 27 | Marietta Mustangs | 4 | WR | Martin Nance | Miami (OH) RedHawks |
| 27 | Willow Island Wannabees | 4 | WR | Craphonso Thorpe | Florida State Seminoles |
| 27 | Huntington Herd | 8 | QB | Joshua Cribbs | Kent State Golden Flashes |
| 26 | Williamstown Shockers | 15 | DT | Wisconsin | Wisconsin Badgers |
| 26 | Huntington Herd | 22 | K | Chris Nendick | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 25 | Charleston Chew | 1 | RB | Anthony Davis | Wisconsin Badgers |
| 25 | Williamstown Shockers | 4 | RB | Kejuan Jones | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 25 | Huntington Herd | 13 | DT | Marshall | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 24 | Warwood Warriors | 17 | RB | Noah Herron | Northwestern Wildcats |
| 23 | Valley Litigators | 11 | DT | Louisiana State | Louisiana State Tigers |
| 23 | Charleston Chew | 14 | DT | Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech Hokies |
| 23 | Williamstown Shockers | 19 | WR | Todd Blythe | Iowa State Cyclones |
| 19 | Huntington Herd | 14 | K | Jon Peattie | Miami (FL) Hurricanes |
| 19 | AAMAC | 22 | WR | Courtney Roby | Indiana Hoosiers |
| 19 | Williamstown Shockers | 22 | RB | Pierre Thomas | Illinois Fighting Illini |
| 18 | Willow Island Wannabees | 10 | RB | Jerry Seymour | Central Michigan Chippewas |
| 18 | Charleston Chew | 16 | DT | West Virginia | West Virginia Mountaineers |
| 17 | Willow Island Wannabees | 2 | RB | Justin Vincent | Louisiana State Tigers |
| 17 | Valley Litigators | 8 | WR | Tramain Hall | North Carolina State Wolfpack |
| 17 | Marietta Mustangs | 10 | QB | Vince Young | Texas Longhorns |
| 17 | Warwood Warriors | 10 | RB | Frank Gore | Miami (FL) Hurricanes |
| 17 | AAMAC | 17 | DT | Ohio | Ohio Bobcats |
| 16 | AAMAC | 11 | K | Matt Leach | Florida Gators |
| 16 | Valley Litigators | 17 | DT | Florida State | Florida State Seminoles |
| 15 | AAMAC | 18 | WR | Troy Williamson | South Carolina Gamecocks |
| 14 | AAMAC | 5 | WR | Fred Gibson | Georgia Bulldogs |
| 14 | Huntington Herd | 10 | WR | Airese Currie | Clemson Tiger |
| 12 | Warwood Warriors | 3 | QB | Charlie Frye | Akron Zips |
| 11 | Warwood Warriors | 7 | RB | Lydell Ross | Ohio State Buckeyes |
| 11 | Charleston Chew | 8 | WR | Skyler Green | Louisiana State Tigers |
| 11 | Huntington Herd | 18 | WR | Darrell Dowery | Kent State Golden Flashes |
| 11 | Willow Island Wannabees | 19 | WR | Bristol Olomua | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 10 | Warwood Warriors | 14 | RB | Jason Colson | West Virginia Mountaineers |
| 10 | Williamstown Shockers | 21 | WR | Steve Sanders | Bowling Green Falcons |
| 9 | AAMAC | 7 | RB | Josh Allen | Maryland Terrapins |
| 9 | Huntington Herd | 16 | DT | Iowa | Iowa Hawkeyes |
| 8 | Charleston Chew | 12 | WR | Bill Flowers | Mississippi Rebels |
| 8 | Valley Litigators | 20 | WR | Mark Philmore | Northwestern Wildcats |
| 7 | AAMAC | 14 | QB | Marcus Randall | Louisiana State Tigers |
| 7 | Valley Litigators | 16 | K | Todd Pegram | Texas A&M Aggies |
| 6 | Marietta Mustangs | 11 | DT | Georgia | Georgia Bulldogs |
| 6 | Willow Island Wannabees | 20 | WR | Jason Williams | Connecticut Huskies |
| 6 | Marietta Mustangs | 21 | WR | Kenny Higgins | Toledo Rockets |
| 5 | Marietta Mustangs | 20 | K | Alex Trilica, Texas Tech | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 4 | Huntington Herd | 9 | K | Jared Parseghian | Miami (OH) RedHawks |
| 3 | AAMAC | 6 | RB | Cedric Houston | Tennessee Volunteers |
| 3 | Marietta Mustangs | 18 | WR | Calvin Johnson, Ga Tech | Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets |
| 3 | Williamstown Shockers | 18 | RB | Ibrahim Haulsey | Illinois Fighting Illini |
| 3 | AAMAC | 21 | RB | Cornell Brockington | Connecticut Huskies |
| 2 | Williamstown Shockers | 2 | RB | Earl Charles | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 2 | Valley Litigators | 6 | WR | Tyrone Moss | Miami (FL) Hurricanes |
| 2 | AAMAC | 10 | RB | Jerod Void | Purdue Boilermakers |
| 2 | Williamstown Shockers | 13 | DT | Kansas State | Kansas State Wildcats |
| 2 | Marietta Mustangs | 14 | RB | P.J. Daniels | Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets |
| 2 | Williamstown Shockers | 14 | QB | Darian Durant | North Carolina Tarheels |
| 2 | Marietta Mustangs | 17 | RB | BenJarvus Green-Ellis | Indiana Hoosiers |
| 2 | Williamstown Shockers | 17 | RB | Lorenzo Booker | Florida State Seminoles |
| 2 | Valley Litigators | 19 | RB | Tony Hunt | Penn State Nittany Lions |
| 2 | Huntington Herd | 20 | K | Matt Prater | Central Florida Golden Knights |
| 2 | Willow Island Wannabees | 21 | WR | Santonio Holmes | Ohio State Buckeyes |
| 1 | Williamstown Shockers | 8 | WR | Brandon Jones | Oklahoma Sooners |
| 1 | Marietta Mustangs | 12 | WR | Mark Simmons | Kansas Jayhawks |
| 1 | Marietta Mustangs | 15 | WR | Jason Anderson | Wake Forest Demon Deacons |
| 1 | Valley Litigators | 15 | WR | Andre Caldwell | Florida Gators |
| 1 | Willow Island Wannabees | 16 | DT | Minnesota | Minnesota Golden Gophers |
| 1 | Huntington Herd | 17 | RB | Ahmad Bradshaw | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 1 | Willow Island Wannabees | 23 | DT | Northern Illinois | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 2 | RB | Kay-Jay Harris | West Virginia Mountaineers |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 5 | WR | Princell Brockenbrough | Pittsburgh Panthers |
| 0 | Willow Island Wannabees | 5 | QB | Stan Hill | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 0 | Huntington Herd | 6 | WR | Ron Monteilh | Colorado Buffaloes |
| 0 | Williamstown Shockers | 6 | QB | Joshua Haldi | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 7 | RB | Courtney Lewis | Texas A&M Aggies |
| 0 | AAMAC | 8 | QB | Chris Rix | Florida State Seminoles |
| 0 | Marietta Mustangs | 8 | WR | Isaiah Fluellen | Nebraska Cornhuskers |
| 0 | AAMAC | 9 | WR | Jonathan Orr | Wisconsin Badgers |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 9 | QB | Brock Berlin | Miami (FL) Hurricanes |
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 9 | WR | Brandon Williams | Wisconsin Badgers |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 10 | K | Aleks Miskov | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 0 | Williamstown Shockers | 10 | RB | Trinity Dawson | Toledo Rockets |
| 0 | Huntington Herd | 11 | WR | Mike Espy | Mississippi Rebels |
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 11 | WR | Ryan Moore | Miami (FL) Hurricanes |
| 0 | Williamstown Shockers | 11 | WR | Heath Miller | Virginia Cavaliers |
| 0 | AAMAC | 12 | WR | Jason Avant | Michigan Wolverines |
| 0 | Huntington Herd | 12 | RB | A.J. Harris | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 12 | RB | Kregg Lumpkin | Georgia Bulldogs |
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 12 | WR | Matt Herian | Nebraska Cornhuskers |
| 0 | Marietta Mustangs | 13 | WR | Shatone Powers | Northern Illinois Huskies |
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 13 | QB | Charlie Whitehurst | Clemson Tiger |
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 13 | QB | Walter Washington | Temple Owls |
| 0 | Willow Island Wannabees | 13 | QB | David Greene | Georgia Bulldogs |
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 14 | WR | Ross Pilkington | Nebraska Cornhuskers |
| 0 | Willow Island Wannabees | 14 | WR | Hiram Moore | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 0 | Huntington Herd | 15 | WR | Tremel Guillory | Marshall Thundering Herd |
| 0 | Willow Island Wannabees | 15 | WR | Ryan Hamby | Ohio State Buckeyes |
| 0 | AAMAC | 16 | RB | Jabari Davis | Tennessee Volunteers |
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 16 | K | Brandon Pace | Virginia Tech Hokies |
| 0 | Willow Island Wannabees | 17 | WR | Andrew Clarke | Toledo Rockets |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 18 | |||
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 18 | |||
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 19 | |||
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 19 | |||
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 20 | |||
| 0 | Warwood Warriors | 20 | |||
| 0 | Williamstown Shockers | 20 | QB | Adam Barmann | Kansas Jayhawks |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 21 | |||
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 21 | |||
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 22 | |||
| 0 | Marietta Mustangs | 22 | WR | Trey Haverty | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 22 | |||
| 0 | Willow Island Wannabees | 22 | RB | Johnnie Mack | Texas Tech Red Raiders |
| 0 | AAMAC | 23 | QB | Gavin Dickey | Florida Gators |
| 0 | Charleston Chew | 23 | |||
| 0 | Valley Litigators | 23 | |||
| 0 | Williamstown Shockers | 23 | RB | John Randle | Kansas Jayhawks |
| Warwood Warriors | 21 | ||||
| Warwood Warriors | 22 | ||||
| Huntington Herd | 23 | WR | Domenik Hixon | Akron Zips | |
| Warwood Warriors | 23 |